Chapter 1 - The Concept
There’s this concept that I’ve learned and live with, and it goes like this:
There is a degree of knowing a thing that is deep and personal. This kind of knowing is beyond cognitive. This known thing is embedded in the knower’s heart and displayed in the knower’s living - influencing his decisions and changing his responses to circumstances.
I often refer to this known thing as, “something you’ve learned yourself,” or, “something God has taught to your heart,” or, “something your heart has learned deeply,” et cetera. It stands apart from cognitively agreeing with an idea, especially one that someone else has offered.
Donald Miller says (something like) if one doesn’t live out what one says he believes, then he must not really believe it. This is the same vein of thought as I’m bringing up in this post.
Finally (in describing the concept), I’ll say that the things that one comes to learn and know are of utmost value in life. These known things turn out to be some of the treasures that moths can’t chew at nor anyone could ever steal. I believe all should tack great worth to these known things and be willing to die to honor them.
Chapter 2 - Disconnects From Real Life
Identifying what we truly know is difficult on two accounts: 1) a known thing can be abstract, unclear, have fuzzy edges, and wobble around based on the circumstance its in. And 2) it can be disturbing to find out that we have no lived-out evidence that we actually do believe a thing we say we believe.
The first difficulty will sort its own way out. We will read a sentence in a book or see a deed done or hear a speaker say something, and all of a sudden that abstract thing will become articulated, the fuzzy edges will turn clear. Merely have patience and believe that the Great Teacher intends to teach it to your more fully in due time. The second difficulty… well, you need to get over it.
I’ve found that I’ve never deeply learned most things I’ve been taught that I should believe. Yes, this is disturbing.¹
And to even further trash (some of) my readers’ trust in me, the Bible doesn’t seem to be about most of the things that I’ve truly learned the deepest. Sure, I could use the Bible as a tool to support those great things that I’ve learned, but I’d be working backwards: creating my thesis first and addressing the Bible second. Perhaps the Bible’s authors would agree that the things I’ve learned are of primary value, but they considered those things so basic and obvious that they failed to talk about them explicitly in the Bible.
Most of the primary religions (including Christianity) have a sort of list of precepts that their adherents must adopt. The adoption of these precepts is funny, because there can be little enforcement or proof about an adherent adopting a precept. An adherent can adopt a precept in practice, in cognitive agreement, deeply within his heart, a mix of these, or not at all and say he does. In the traditional Christianity of the last century, things like scriptural inerrancy, the fall of mankind, the coming of Christ, the death/resurrection of Jesus, salvation by grace, et cetera comprise that list. Here’s an example. I find it quite… question-inducing that this list be made up of such intellectual/psychological items. They’re things that are cognitively decided upon to be true or false. Two people can have completely identical lifestyles, yet one can deem those items true, and the other deem them false, and, in popular Christianity, one person will be eternally blessed while the other is eternally tortured.
In any case, I write that to point out that I don’t particularly think that most of the items on the list of Christian doctrinal essentials have buried themselves (or were buried by God) deep into my heart. I haven’t learned most of them for myself. Most of them don’t create the story in which that I live out my life, even at my best moments as my best self.
Chapter 3 - Some of My Deeply Known Things
Here are some of the things I believe in. These are an example. They will seem arbitrary. There’s too much pressure and holiness in the task of making a comprehensive presentation, at least at this point in my life.
The Virtue of Learning/Growing - God’s promise of continually shaping us into the image of Christ is one of my very favorite promises in scripture. But [he] doesn’t do it without cooperation. In virtually every moment of our lives, there are things to learn; ways to grow. We become more powerful and influential, more magical and sensitive, stronger in our strengths and more balanced in our weaknesses. We become more an asset to the world and to God’s intended story for the world. And not only do we grow individually, but as societies and as a species, able to turn tides of history.
Self honesty - I remember at about age 19 realizing the freedom that comes from confronting the things in our lives we naturally don’t want to look at, out of self preservation. It takes a certain amount of strength and resolve to stop lying to ourselves about this or that.
God’s conspiracy of blessing humans - In all ways, God leads toward greatness, treasure, fulfilled destiny, and heavenly riches for the whole world. We would have to try hard to ignore, to deviate, to deny, and to reject the path of blessing that [he] guides us towards.
Infinite worth in each life - Regardless of what anyone deserves or not, each person is invaluable, and we should endeavor to come to the place of laying down our lives for anyone.
Sanctity of non-human life - Animals and plants should be treasured and respected.
I don’t declare that these things should be the new list that everyone needs to cognitively agree with in order to get into heaven. These things are some of the things that I’ve learned deeply. I would die for these values.
Bright Eyes - Bad Blood (Lyrics)

¹A brighter way of looking at this disturbance is to realize that humans learn more by example than by speech - and that the things that my teachers (parents, etc.) deeply knew, they could never conceal, because those things were lived out. So in a sense, I did truly learn some of the things that they truly knew.²If anyone knows the artist of this image, please let me know.